2012-01-19 submit to reddit

SOPA Stalls, But Online Experts Advise Caution

Amid Internet site blackouts and public outcries, the Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA) has been placed on hold in the Senate while sponsors regroup and reconsider their position on this controversial topic. Along with its companion bill, the Protect IP Act (PIPA), SOPA has aroused the ire of many in the computing and online commerce field who value the free and open access to information that the Internet provides for its users. While initial protests came primarily from computing organizations, civil liberties organizations and left-wing political movements, a number of right-of-center groups including Heritage Action and conservative blog site RedState have recently added their voices to oppose SOPA and PIPA as well.

What are SOPA and PIPA?

Both SOPA and PIPA are designed to target online piracy of copyrighted material; SOPA is the bill currently before the U.S. Senate, while PIPA is being considered by the House of Representatives. Music, movie and other file sharing sites often operate in violation of U.S. and international copyright law and may be targeted by law enforcement agencies for these violations under existing laws. Rather than targeting these sites directly, SOPA and PIPA are aimed at the Internet service providers (ISPs), domain name server (DNS) providers and search engines that provide access for the file sharing sites. While SOPA targets ISPs directly, PIPA also applies to a broad range of other Internet services including search engines, online financial services and DNS providers. Both bills are considered to pose a significant threat to the free and open access to information that most Internet users have enjoyed thus far.

Vanishing support in Congress

While public opposition to SOPA and PIPA has been loud and persistent, there are signs that Congress is quietly getting the message. A co-sponsor of PIPA and two co-sponsors of SOPA withdrew their sponsorships and their support for these bills in response to the ongoing protests. Marco Rubio, a Republican senator from Florida, explained his change of heart on PIPA by citing “legitimate concerns about the impact the bill could have.” Republican senator Lamar Smith announced that he planned to eliminate the clause in SOPA that would restrict access to certain foreign websites accused or suspected of participating in online piracy, a provision backed by major copyright holders in the movie and music industries.

Threats to Internet access remain

Even after the removal of the provision that would block access to certain foreign websites, the SOPA legislation still includes language that would allow or force ISPs to refuse to provide services to any website that “engages in, enables or facilitates” online piracy or copyright infringement. Opponents of SOPA argue that this language is so vague as to include nearly all websites on the Internet, with blogs and social networking sites especially vulnerable to the application or misapplication of the SOPA legislation. While this initial battle appears to have been won, most experts predict that SOPA and PIPA will return in some form during the next legislative session.

kimberly author

Kimberly Dovander


Kimberly is the pro blogger in the WHS family. WordPress, Blogger, Tumblr... It doesn't matter - she knows them all. Send her a question, or a drop a line in the comment section below, and she'll get back to you.

Add Your Thoughts

  • 2012-02-22

    Access to Website Taken Down by US Order

    One of the fears of those who opposed the passage of the SOPA/PIPA Internet anti-piracy legislation in the US Congress last month may have come true. Many in the web hosting industry are concerned over the growi...
    us secret service
  • 2012-02-16

    Lessons Learned from Hack Attacks

    The importance of keeping customers in the loop and making them feel an integral part of a web hosting provider's business was driven home by the recent hack attack on the Cryptome.org web site. Covering whistle...
  • providers giving advise
    2012-02-15

    Web Hosting Providers Acting As Advisors

    Yahoo has recently taken a step for interaction with the customer that all web hosting providers may want to think about emulating. Last week, the beta of Yahoo Small Business premiered to the public as a resour...
  • ipv6 launch
    2012-02-09

    World IPv6 Launch Day Coming Soon

    The Internet Society recently set a date, June 6, 2012, as World IPv6 Launch Day, when it is expected that web companies and major Internet Service Providers (ISPs) will permanently enable the IPv6 protocol for ...
  • 2012-02-07

    SOPA and PIPA Lobbying Payments

    Last month, the United States Congress stopped consideration of two bills, the Stop Online Privacy Act (SOPA) in the US Senate and the Protect Intellectual Property Act (PIPA) in the US House of Representatives,...
  • 2012-01-31

    Problems for DreamHost

    Other web host providers may take a lesson from the recent set of problems that have been the experience of DreamHost, a domain name registrar and web hosting provider founded in 1996 and based in Los Angeles, C...
    dreamhost problems
  • open index
    2012-01-31

    Will New Online Protection Bill Replace SOPA and PIPA?

    With the overwhelming reaction against the Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA) and the PROTECT IP Act (PIPA), a few members of the United States Congress have put forth an alternative bill. Oregon Democrat Senator Ron...
  • 2012-01-30

    A Closer Look at Magento

    At its simplest, Magento is a robust e-commerce solution built on a foundation of open-source technologies. The blended approach that Magento uses provides the best of both worlds for end-users. On one hand, the...
  • new gtld signing
    2012-01-24

    Smooth Start for New gTLD Program

    ICANN, the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers, announced last week that the application system for the new gTLDs (Generic Top-Level Domains) of the Internet began on January 19th and is proceedi...
  • 2012-01-18

    Security Breach for Zappos Customers

    Over the weekend, Zappos, the online store famous for its vast array of shoes for sale, announced that personal confidential information, including such items as email addresses, partial credit card numbers and ...
    Security Breach Zappos

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28

Buying Guide

Can't decide what hosting is right for you? Answer 2-5 questions and get your perfect hosting match!

To Questions

User Reviews

Make your voice heard. Review your web hosting provider - good or bad.

  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
Everything has been very stabile and I was very impressed with all the features and extras that were included in the plan.

Bill about iPage

Read iPage Review

Ask the Editor

Editor

Ask us anything about hosting. We love to help.

David Walsh
editor in chief